On synth-1m, what is the total log return of the instrument over the whole sample? Report it as the statistic `total_log_return`, and test the hypothesis that the mean session log return differs from zero (two-sided, 5% level).
- Finished
- 2026-11-12
- Harness
- Claude Code harness
- Models
- planner claude-code:claude-opus-5-5, analyst claude-code:claude-sonnet-5-5, critic claude-code:claude-opus-5-5
- Status
- Completed
- Review
- Passed review
- Dataset
- synth-1m (synthetic)
Every result on this page is on a seeded synthetic dataset with planted effects and traps, not on market data.
Plan
- Hypothesis
- The mean session log return of the roll-adjusted SYN front-month future on synth-1m differs from zero.
- Dataset
- synth-1m
- Window
- 2023-01-02 to 2025-12-31
- Method
- Load synth-1m (symbol SYN). Convert ts from UTC to America/New_York and assign each bar to a trading session: the session runs 18:00 to 17:00 New York time, and a bar at or after 18:00 belongs to the next calendar day's session date. Keep sessions dated 2023-01-02 to 2025-12-31. Sort by ts and compute 1-minute log returns ln(close_t / close_{t-1}) only between consecutive bars of the same contract; the return across each of the 12 contract switches (a roll, not a price move) is dropped, so the series is roll-adjusted. Also drop the return across each session break (17:00 to 18:00) only if the two bars belong to different contracts; otherwise keep it in the session it lands in, so returns sum to the whole-sample move. Session log return = sum of the bar log returns assigned to that session. total_log_return = sum of all session log returns over the sample (equivalently the sum of within-contract bar log returns). Report total_log_return, the number of sessions, the mean and standard deviation of session log returns, and the unadjusted ln(last close / first close) for comparison, which includes the roll gaps.
- Statistic
- total_log_return
- Significance
- Two-sided test of mean session log return = 0 at the 5% level: Newey-West HAC t-test on the session log returns with lag 5 (sessions do not overlap; the lag guards against mild serial correlation), with the plain one-sample t-test reported alongside.
Critic
Review: Passed review
The critic left no open issues.
Report
Research report 20261112T165438Z-76a84d
Status: completed. Harness: claude-code. Dataset: synth-1m.
Question
On synth-1m, what is the total log return of the instrument over the whole sample? Report it as the statistic `total_log_return`, and test the hypothesis that the mean session log return differs from zero (two-sided, 5% level).
Plan
hypothesis = "The mean session log return of the roll-adjusted SYN front-month future on synth-1m differs from zero."
dataset = "synth-1m"
start = 2023-01-02
end = 2025-12-31
method = "Load synth-1m (symbol SYN). Convert ts from UTC to America/New_York and assign each bar to a trading session: the session runs 18:00 to 17:00 New York time, and a bar at or after 18:00 belongs to the next calendar day's session date. Keep sessions dated 2023-01-02 to 2025-12-31. Sort by ts and compute 1-minute log returns ln(close_t / close_{t-1}) only between consecutive bars of the same contract; the return across each of the 12 contract switches (a roll, not a price move) is dropped, so the series is roll-adjusted. Also drop the return across each session break (17:00 to 18:00) only if the two bars belong to different contracts; otherwise keep it in the session it lands in, so returns sum to the whole-sample move. Session log return = sum of the bar log returns assigned to that session. total_log_return = sum of all session log returns over the sample (equivalently the sum of within-contract bar log returns). Report total_log_return, the number of sessions, the mean and standard deviation of session log returns, and the unadjusted ln(last close / first close) for comparison, which includes the roll gaps."
statistic = "total_log_return"
significance = "Two-sided test of mean session log return = 0 at the 5% level: Newey-West HAC t-test on the session log returns with lag 5 (sessions do not overlap; the lag guards against mild serial correlation), with the plain one-sample t-test reported alongside."
Method
- Loaded synth-1m (symbol SYN, 1-minute bars of a continuous front-month future). - Converted timestamps from UTC to America/New_York. Assigned each bar to an 18:00–17:00 session: a bar at or after 18:00 belongs to the next calendar day's session. - Computed 1-minute log returns ln(close_t / close_{t-1}) only between consecutive bars of the same contract. Dropped the 12 returns that cross a contract switch (rolls, not price moves), which gives a roll-adjusted series. - Session log return = the sum of the bar returns in that session. `total_log_return` = the sum over all sessions. - Tested mean session log return = 0, two-sided at 5%, with a Newey-West HAC t-test (lag 5), and reported the plain one-sample t-test alongside. - One analysis pass. The independent critic passed it with no open issues.
Code
Final script: call 1, pass 1.
import numpy as np, pandas as pd, research_io
from scipy import stats
df = research_io.load("synth-1m")
df = df[df.symbol=="SYN"].sort_values("ts").reset_index(drop=True)
ny = df.ts.dt.tz_convert("America/New_York")
sd = ny.dt.normalize().dt.tz_localize(None)
sd = sd.where(ny.dt.hour<18, sd+pd.Timedelta(days=1))
df["sess"]=sd
keep = (df.sess>=pd.Timestamp("2023-01-02"))&(df.sess<=pd.Timestamp("2025-12-31"))
df = df[keep].reset_index(drop=True)
r = np.log(df.close/df.close.shift(1))
same = df.contract==df.contract.shift(1)
valid = same & r.notna()
dropped = int((~same & r.notna()).sum())
s = r[valid].groupby(df.sess[valid]).sum()
n=len(s); x=s.values; m=x.mean(); sdv=x.std(ddof=1)
total=x.sum()
# Newey-West lag 5 on mean
L=5; e=x-m
g0=(e*e).sum()/n
lrv=g0
for l in range(1,L+1):
w=1-l/(L+1)
lrv+=2*w*(e[l:]*e[:-l]).sum()/n
se_nw=np.sqrt(lrv/n); t_nw=m/se_nw; p_nw=2*(1-stats.t.cdf(abs(t_nw),n-1))
t,p=stats.ttest_1samp(x,0)
unadj=float(np.log(df.close.iloc[-1]/df.close.iloc[0]))
res=dict(total_log_return=float(total),n_sessions=n,mean=float(m),sd=float(sdv),unadjusted=unadj,
dropped_returns=dropped,se_nw=float(se_nw),t_nw=float(t_nw),p_nw=float(p_nw),t_plain=float(t),p_plain=float(p))
print(res)
concl="supported" if p_nw<0.05 else "not_supported"
ci=dict(level=0.95,low=float(total-1.96*se_nw*n),high=float(total+1.96*se_nw*n))
research_io.save_result(res,answer=dict(statistic="total_log_return",value=float(total),n=n,conclusion=concl,ci=ci))
Results
Over the whole sample (783 sessions, 2023-01-02 to 2025-12-31), the roll-adjusted total log return of SYN on synth-1m is 0.5658. The mean session log return is 0.000723, and it differs from zero at the 5% level: Newey-West HAC t = 5.20 (p ≈ 2.6e-7), plain t = 4.93 (p ≈ 1.0e-6). The hypothesis is supported. Without the roll adjustment, ln(last/first close) is 0.8073; the 12 contract-roll gaps account for the difference of about 0.24.
- total_log_return = 0.5658025231146101 (n = 783)
- 95% interval: [0.3524232071175124, 0.7791818391117078]
- conclusion: supported
| Quantity | Value | |---|---| | `total_log_return` (roll-adjusted) | **0.5658** | | 95% interval for the total (HAC SE, normal) | 0.352 to 0.779 | | Sessions | 783 | | Mean session log return | 0.000723 | | SD of session log return | 0.00410 | | HAC t (lag 5) / p | 5.20 / ≈2.6e-7 | | Plain t / p | 4.93 / ≈1.0e-6 | | Unadjusted ln(last close / first close) | 0.8073 | | Returns dropped at contract switches | 12 |
The instrument's own price move over the sample is about +0.566 in log terms, roughly +76% compounded. The mean session return is clearly positive: both tests reject zero at far below the 5% level. The naive first-to-last close figure (0.807) overstates the return, because it counts the price jumps at the 12 contract rolls as gains.
Critic findings
Review: passed after 1 critic call(s).
- Pass 1: pass
Caveats
- The data is synthetic (generator seed 20261111), so the result describes the generator, not a real market.
- The headline figure depends on the roll treatment. Dropping the roll-crossing returns is one standard convention; a ratio back-adjustment would give the same total log return, but a difference back-adjustment would not.
- The 95% interval for the total scales the Newey-West standard error of the mean by the number of sessions and uses a normal 1.96 multiplier; it is an approximation.
- The HAC lag of 5 was chosen in advance and not tuned. The plain t-test agrees, so the conclusion does not hinge on it.